The least fashionable slot in Commander deckbuilding is the extra basic land, and it is frequently the correct one. Basics are findable by e...
The least fashionable slot in Commander deckbuilding is the extra basic land, and it is frequently the correct one. Basics are findable by every ramp spell that searches for them, immune to the nonbasic hate that circulates in most metas, and guaranteed to arrive untapped and on colour. A utility land has to beat all of that, on the turns that matter, to deserve the slot.
Real lands, read exactly
Forest — Basic Land — Forest (mana cost ): ({T}: Add {G}.)
Wastes — Basic Land (mana cost ): {T}: Add {C}.
Every land named here can be checked in the MTGBrew card database — mana-base advice should always survive a trip to the oracle text.
How to apply this to your deck
Run the comparison honestly. Ask what the utility land does in three states: the opening hand, the mid-game stall, and the flood. If its best case is a stall you rarely hit, while the basic improves every ramp spell and every early curve in every game, the basic wins. Utility lands earn their place when they answer a named problem in your strategy — a graveyard that needs answering, a hand size that needs ignoring, a board that needs a pump. 'It might be useful someday' is not a named problem, and a mana base full of someday is how decks lose to their own cleverness.
Build the list in the MTGBrew AI deck builder and count your coloured sources colour by colour against the spells you actually cast early; the MTGBrew Learn guides return to this habit in every mana-base piece, because most 'bad luck' in Commander is a mana base quietly miscounted at build time.
If this topic is on your bench, keep going with Aether Vial in Commander: What It Does and Which Decks Want It — it covers the neighbouring decisions from a different angle, and the two pieces together give you a fuller picture than either one alone.
The short version
A mana base is a promise your deck makes to its own curve. Keep the promise measurable — sources per colour, lands that enter untapped when the early game needs them, utility slots that still tap for mana — and the strategy on top of it gets to be the reason you win or lose, instead of the lands deciding before the game starts.
Keep reading
Keep reading: Aether Vial in Commander: What It Does and Which Decks Want It and Cultivate vs Kodama's Reach: Which One Does Your Deck Actually Want?.
COMMENTS